Dreams of One True Autism Resource and Getting Beyond Oral History

by Tim on September 17, 2010

Last night we had our more-or-less-once-a-month family night at school, which basically means many of the parents from the three levels of autism classes (Pre-K, K-2nd, 3rd-5th) get together at school either with the teachers or with outside experts from the community and discuss a particular issue that we’re all struggling with. Not surprisingly, the issue we choose to focus on for the month always fans out into a multitude of other things we’re dealing with.

These are always great evenings, both for learning so much from each other and for fellowship with other parents. It often connects us with some great resources in the community, too. For example, we’re meeting in a couple of weeks with the special needs trust attorney we connected with at a previous family night.

One major issue that dawned on me last night was that without these nights at school there’s so much valuable expertise and information we’d miss out on. The collective experience between the dozen or so families that regularly come to these, the teachers and therapists, and experts from the community who come speak to us is amazing. We get together in the room and share what we know, have learned from our own experience, or found out from our research. We are in a sense passing down an oral history of what we’ve learned to each member in our little tribe of great parents.

It’s a godsend that we can do this, but it’s also incredibly inefficient. We’re all the time reinventing the wheel. Someone goes through the process of filling out paperwork for disability services or getting a handicap placard or resubmitting claims to Medicaid, learns a lot, but that learning isn’t easily preserved. So the next person who goes through it may not know which of us to ask, tries to get some part of the way down the road themselves, gets as lost as the person before them did, gets frustrated, and so on. Eventually they’ll find a person who has already been through whatever the problem is (well, assuming someone has), talk to them, and start to get unstuck. But in the meantime, so much time and energy is lost – time and energy none of us have to spare. Facebook groups, listserves, forums, Twitter, blogs, etc. all have an equivalent problem – little of the information posted is preserved in a way that can easily be accessed later by the entire autism community.

But how do we preserve this knowledge? I’ve given serious thought to developing a wiki for our school. That would at least be a start. Obviously there’s information everywhere online, but that’s both a blessing and a curse. There’s so much information scattered everywhere, but it’s rarely that organized, often out-of-date, wrong, or perhaps even intentionally false, and quickly too overwhelming to do anything with. I don’t need eleventybillion pages of information about something; I just want someone to give me the freakin’ answer to my question.

I dream of a central repository of process knowledge, “How do I do X?” sorts of information and instruction sets. Yeah, I realize that a lot of our challenges aren’t easily reduced to instruction sets, but a number of things can be. For many other issues, at least people can generate a few, high-quality ideas to get people started or nudged a few more feet down the path. I know it’d be a monumental undertaking, but collectively we are wasting God knows how many billions of hours a year trying to find information we need about how to do everything from the simple to the complex.

Would it be possible just to have some resource that filters out all the roaring noise about vaccines, causes and cures, controversial treatments, and whatever else and just gives practical, day-to-day information we need like how to fill out this frackin’ form for disability services or what the hell all these acronyms mean? The end result of all of our yelling and infighting and carrying on is that this sort of resource does not exist because what energy we have left over after being parents is consumed by all this other stuff. And it’s great that we are spending so much time and effort on the critical work of educating the world about autism, but it’s also essential that we remember to educate each other on how to live and do the best for our children.

I know it’s unrealistic to expect one site to handle everything, but humor the ideal a little. Even the process of aiming toward that goal should yield something a bazillion times better than what we have now. I’d rather have potentially ridiculous and unrealistic goals than have all of us keep pounding our keyboards in frustration.

Anybody interested in talking about this further? It would obviously be an enormous undertaking requiring a whole lot of people, but there are more than a whole lot of us out there and I know we’re all tired of banging our heads against our computers trying to find what we need. Maybe one of the greatest gifts we can give each other is saved time. Together we are stronger than we are on our own.

Oral traditions eventually developed writing, libraries, and ways to communicate large quantities of information quickly. In a way, maybe that’s a roadmap for us, too. Perhaps we don’t even need a map. Maybe all we need is to just sit down and start writing and connecting the dots for each other.

Posts that hopefully are similar:

{ 7 comments… read them below or add one }

Daniel Kirk September 17, 2010 at 10:19 pm

A wiki isn’t a bad idea, especially with some ground rules about off-limits topics and civil behavior. The problem I see is that each state develops its own programs, and each program develops its own forms, acronyms, etc. Then each school or district adds another layer of bureaucracy with forms, policies, and procedures incompatible with those of many other districts. All this to say that it would be extremely helpful to be able to limit searches geographically at each level.

Liz Ditz September 19, 2010 at 12:14 pm

We’ve been gathering resources at The Thinking Person’s Guide to Autism, but Daniel makes some really sound points. “The Way Things Work” at School District #1 isn’t the “The Way Things Work” at School District #2– even if they are in the same LEA (Local Education Authority).

Tim September 21, 2010 at 1:43 pm

Daniel and Liz,

Thanks for the great feedback. I’ve been thinking about this off and on the last couple of days. I completely agree with your comments. I got to wondering whether a viable approach would be to – borrowing a phrase a co-worker of mine used – document the hell out of everything you can related to your city and county, learn the best ways of organizing that information, and then use that as a duplicatable (sorry if I just made up a word) model for other people to use for their own areas. This way one person or group of people isn’t really responsible for documenting the whole world, but everybody can learn good ways to compile that information without having to think through all those organizing and technical issues every time. It does sort of feel like trying to empty the Great Lakes using a coffee spoon, but it is possible.

I guess it boils down to two major issues we’re all facing: 1) we all know the lack of information is a problem, and 2) we aren’t sure of the best ways of addressing that problem. I do know there are a lot of good people busting their behinds to improve this (e.g., The Thinking Person’s Guide to Autism), and knowing that gives me a lot of energy and hope.

Tim September 21, 2010 at 7:01 pm

Liz,

I’ve been reading The Thinking Person’s Guide to Autism pretty much since the beginning, and it is an incredible site – easily one of the best sites going right now in my opinion. I’ve been working on a piece to submit, and actually will assuming I can get a couple more hours of time carved out around here to finish it. :-)

What’s floating around in my head feels different than TPGA. I imagine TPGA will evolve into something like an autism canon that as a resource will probably surpass just about anything in the bookstore or online in the area of what to read to find your footing and your climbing legs while looking for a path up the mountain. The quality of the information on TPGA is stellar with an author’s list that reads like a Who’s Who.

Some of the step-by-step or wiki-type information I’ve been wanting to get compiled somehow feels more reference-y (nicer way of saying mundane, perhaps) than what TPGA seems to be aiming toward. To try to come up with a probably lame analogy, TPGA might be like those wonderful books about cuisine that teaches you a lot you didn’t know, inspires you to go make some great food, and gives you some idea how to do it, and what I’ve been pondering perhaps is more the gory details of taking the stuff in your fridge and pantry and building what you want out of it. This obviously isn’t a hard-and-fast rule since there are posts like “Creating a Special Needs Binder” that are very much the kinds of information I’d like to see compiled somewhere more and more.

This is just my opinion, but I think if TPGA tried to go in-depth in all these directions it would lose something valuable it currently has. It’s hard for me to describe it, but the personal connection I feel with a lot of the posts there comes from how I identify with the real-life stories the writers are telling and the truths they are expressing. They get at the heart of our shared experience as parents, our common challenges and struggles, and our solidarity in doing our absolute best for our kids and for all people. It’s the honesty and power of those stories that draw me in. I read for the connection and the new ideas it sparks in me, not necessarily how to do something in detail (though that’s great, too) but the inspiration and creativity to go deal with it and make it happen. I hope this is something TPGA sticks to as it really speaks to me.

Not sure any of this made sense. Still trying to sort it out. If anyone reading this takes nothing else away from my rambling comment, go check out The Thinking Person’s Guide to Autism. It’s well worth your time.

Daniel Kirk September 21, 2010 at 10:32 pm

I agree about the need for both TGPA and an online reference emphasizing the how-to. I was wondering if it were possible–I’ve never set up or contributed to a wiki–to make a reference where you could search, for example, “IEP”, and find:
1. An article about IEP’s: what they are, who needs one, how they are used, etc.
2. A step-by-step how-to guide to writing an IEP, generalized for most school districts in most states.
and
3. Links to specific articles about the ins and outs* of writing and implementing an IEP in each of several (as many as are contributed) states and/or districts. *i.e., key pieces/wording/documentation to include, and mistakes/errors/pitfalls to avoid

Danette September 22, 2010 at 11:19 am

I certainly don’t have the answer, but have thought about this question a lot. My contribution to this problem is a 3-part series of guides that walk parents through the problem-solving process of “what do I do?” and “where do I go?” when they receive or suspect a diagnosis. The guides also offer lots of resources with synopses. As a parent of a child with special needs, I have done tons of research (not unlike all the other parents), and decided to get the info out there so that all parents do not have to reinvent the wheel and spend an incredible amount of time finding this info. I also have a blog http://www.sos-research-blog.com full of lots of free resources, tips, book reviews & giveaways, etc. Thanks!

Tim September 23, 2010 at 1:11 pm

Daniel – good thoughts. IEPs are an interesting example that point out another issue. I’d say right now the go-to site for IEPs is Wrightslaw, and while I find it great for its exhaustive and authoritative information, I find it rather difficult to locate a specific piece of information there or simple-to-follow, step-by-step instructions for whatever I’m working on. It’s a fantastic resource, but I think its usability could be greatly improved. With respect to this post, a question might be whether to try to improve existing resources like Wrightslaw or build a new resource from scratch. A third approach might be for someone to just build a list of links to various pages on Wrightslaw or wherever that combine into one list the best IEP resources that answer people’s most common questions and needs – sort of like a roadmap or a set of steps where each step links you to a good, existing online resource. Maybe such a thing already exists. Therein lies the conundrum. We don’t want to reinvent every wheel, but we often don’t know where the wheels are to start with. If we can address those two issues, that would be a great leap forward in my opinion.

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: